You Won't Believe Which 10 ‘House of the Week’ Features Shocked Readers in 2025! Are You Missing Out?

For over 60 years, Central New York's real estate landscape has been shaped by an endearing tradition: the “House of the Week” feature from The Post-Standard and later Syracuse.com. This cherished weekly spotlight provides homeowners with a platform to share what makes their spaces special, while also engaging potential buyers with unique stories and vibrant photographs.

This year, as part of the ongoing feature, a diverse array of homes was showcased, ranging from picturesque lakeside retreats to expansive family residences and beautifully renovated properties. The unique architecture and diverse price points ensure that there’s something for everyone in Central New York's real estate market.

As we move into 2026, the public's interest in these properties has been palpable. Readers can send their nominations for next year’s features to [email protected]. Here's a look at the ten most popular homes featured in 2025, based on views from syracuse.com.

The Top Ten Houses of 2025

Leading the pack is a stunning home in Marcellus, notable for its heated indoor pool. The property at 4873 Lawless Road was a personal dream for Aaron Barbaro, who not only purchased 60 acres of land but also built his five-bedroom home from the ground up. Completed in 2006, this unique dwelling includes an expansive indoor pool with a dedicated heating system, making it ideal for year-round entertainment.

Second on the list is 8067 Irish Mist Lane in Manlius, where Andy and Tracy Schwab sought a spacious family home during the pandemic. The couple's move in September 2020 brought them to a custom Colonial featuring a heated saltwater pool, a perfect backdrop for family fun and relaxation.

In Cazenovia, 71 Forman Street shines as another favorite. Dr. Joseph Catania has lovingly restored his Colonial Revival Victorian home, originally built in 1892. The residence has retained its historic charm while being meticulously cared for, showcasing the love and dedication that Catania has poured into it over nearly three decades.

The Gleason family’s home at 2394 River Road near Weedsport, set on over 33 acres along the serene Seneca River, also captured the public's attention. Brian and Jessica Gleason envisioned a peaceful life away from the city, where their daughters could explore nature freely.

Another standout, 7311 Barberry Lane in Manlius, was an artist's dream project for Barbara Meyer, who designed her mid-century ranch home amidst woods and ponds to prioritize serenity and creativity. The home, a marvel of thoughtful design, became a natural playground for her children.

At 315 Starksboro Drive in Camillus, Paul and Lisa Vitale found their "ultimate family house," where they've hosted numerous gatherings. Their property, stretching over 8.22 acres, provided ample space for family fun, including ziplining and backyard sledding.

Jean Byrne’s home at 2310 Olanco Road on Otisco Lake is a remarkable story of transformation. Byrne fell in love with the site in 2018, ultimately demolishing the original structure and building a new home that pays homage to her family's history on the lake.

The Bostwicks, nature enthusiasts, fulfilled their dream at 3830 Rippleton Road, where they designed a home that reflects their love for the outdoors. Their property, encompassing 93 acres, is a true haven for hiking, biking, and other outdoor activities.

Dr. Jim Vlassis’ home at 8524 Lamp Post Circle in Manlius offers a year-round outdoor experience, with amenities like a pavilion featuring radiant heaters and a hot tub, creating an idyllic setting for family gatherings even in winter.

Finally, the historic 3721 Cold Springs Road in Baldwinsville, dating back to 1808, became a labor of love for Karen Mento and her husband, who undertook extensive renovations to transform the farmhouse into a family gathering place.

With such a rich variety of houses capturing the imagination of local readers, the “House of the Week” feature not only highlights unique properties but also showcases the stories and dreams of the people who inhabit them. It’s a powerful reminder of how homes are more than just structures; they are the heart of our memories and experiences. As we look ahead to 2026, the anticipation for what stories will unfold next is palpable.